If you are looking for motels in Shelter Island, you have come to right hotel booking website, save money on Shelter Island motels by choosing the budget hotel room option available. Most popular motels in Shelter Island are Rodeway Inn, Americas Best Value Inn New London Mystic and Montauk Blue Hotel. If you are looking for value and convenience these 2 star Motels and 3 star Motels are the best way to save money. If you're traveling on a limited budget, save up to 50% on some of the most affordable and cheaper lodging options in the Shelter Island area.